🔒 Regulated brokers only — all FINRA/SIPC members | 📅 Data verified March 2026 — verify at FINRA.org
Affiliate disclosure: Some links on this page may be affiliate links. If you open an account through one, ETF BFF may earn a referral fee at no extra cost to you. Our editorial rankings and research are independent and not influenced by compensation. Learn more.

The short answer

For most ETF investors in 2026, Fidelity or Charles Schwab are the strongest all-around choices — both offer $0 commissions, no account minimums, excellent ETF selection, and platforms that work for beginners and experienced investors alike. If you want auto-rebalancing, M1 Finance is the standout. For international ETF access, Interactive Brokers has no real competition. And if you already bank with Bank of America, Merrill Edge is worth a serious look. All 10 brokerages on this page are FINRA/SIPC members with no ETF commissions — the differences come down to platform, tools, and fit.

Skip to the full comparison ↓

🎯 Who this page is for

Investors evaluating their first brokerage account for ETF investing
People considering switching brokerages and wondering if it’s worth the move
Anyone researching current transfer bonuses before initiating an ACAT
Investors comparing 2–3 brokers who want one source covering all of them

Side-by-Side Brokerage Comparison

The metrics that actually matter for long-term ETF investors. Commissions are $0 across the board — we stopped leading with that years ago.

Brokerage ETF Commission ETF Selection Account Min. Transfer Bonus Mobile Rating
Best all-around for most investors
$0 10,000+ $0 Up to $2,500 → 4.8 / 5
2,000+ no-transaction-fee ETFs
$0 2,000+ NTF $0 Up to $1,000 → 4.7 / 5
The OG low-cost investing platform
$0 All major ETFs $0 None 4.2 / 5
IBKR Lite: $0; global ETF access
$0 (Lite) 13,000+ global $0 None 4.5 / 5
Fractional shares + auto-rebalance
$0 6,000+ $100 Up to $500 → 4.6 / 5
Simplest interface; fractional shares
$0 2,000+ $0 1% match promo → 4.4 / 5
$0 ETF trades; strong options tools
$0 1,800+ $0 Up to $4,000 → 4.3 / 5
Power platform + solid retirement tools
$0 6,500+ $0 Up to $3,500 → 4.4 / 5
Best for Bank of America customers
$0 2,800+ $0 Up to $600 → 4.3 / 5
Advanced charting; fractional shares
$0 5,000+ $0 Current promos → 4.5 / 5

📅 Data verified March 2026. Commission structures, bonuses, and features change frequently. Always confirm current terms directly on each broker's official website before opening an account or initiating a transfer.

Find Your Best Match

Not everyone needs the same broker. Here’s the fastest shortcut by investor type.

🌱

Goal

New to investing

Fidelity or Schwab
🏦

Goal

Opening a Roth IRA

Fidelity or E*TRADE
🔄

Goal

Set it and forget it

M1 Finance
🌍

Goal

International ETF access

Interactive Brokers
📊

Goal

ETFs + options strategies

tastytrade

Broker Deep-Dives

A quick research buddy breakdown for each one. Not a ranking — just the stuff worth knowing before you decide.

#1 Fidelity
Best Overall

Fidelity is the only major broker offering zero-expense-ratio index funds (FZROX at 0.00%) alongside full ETF access at $0 commission. Customer service scores rank consistently among the highest in the industry — which matters when you actually need to call someone.

✅ Pros
  • Zero-ER index funds (FZROX)
  • Best-in-class customer service
  • Fractional shares on 1,000s of ETFs
  • Excellent tax-loss harvesting tools
⚠️ Watch out
  • Platform can feel complex initially
  • Transfer bonus terms change often
Open Account at Fidelity →
#2 Charles Schwab
Best Long-Term

Schwab's post-TD Ameritrade merger brought 2,000+ no-transaction-fee ETFs and one of the cheapest proprietary fund lineups anywhere — SCHB at 0.03%, SCHD at 0.06%. Three-fund portfolio investors who want to buy once and stay tend to land here.

✅ Pros
  • 2,000+ NTF ETFs
  • Ultra-cheap proprietary ETFs
  • $0 minimum, great education
⚠️ Watch out
  • Some TD merger platform quirks remain
  • Intelligent Portfolios requires $5K
Open Account at Schwab →
#3 Vanguard
Vanguard Faithful

Vanguard invented the index fund. If you want to hold VTI, VXUS, and BND and appreciate the mutual ownership structure, there is a philosophical argument for staying in-house. The platform has improved significantly but still lags on UX.

✅ Pros
  • Investor-owned (profits → fund holders)
  • Industry-lowest expense ratios
  • $0 commissions, $0 minimum
⚠️ Watch out
  • Platform UX lags Fidelity/Schwab
  • No transfer bonus offered
  • Fractional shares limited to Vanguard funds
Open Account at Vanguard →
#4 Interactive Brokers
Best International

IBKR Lite gives $0 commissions on 13,000+ ETFs, including non-US listed funds unavailable at Fidelity or Schwab. If you want European-listed ETFs, currency-hedged variants, or emerging market exposure beyond US funds, IBKR is the only realistic option. Real learning curve.

✅ Pros
  • 13,000+ ETFs including global
  • Best international ETF access
  • $0 min; IBKR Pro adds price improvement
⚠️ Watch out
  • Steep learning curve
  • Overkill for casual investors
Open Account at IBKR →
#5 M1 Finance
Best Auto-Invest

M1 is built around automation. Build a “pie” of ETFs with target percentages; every deposit auto-rebalances toward your allocation. If you want to set a target and let recurring deposits do the work, the automation is the product. If you want real-time trading, look elsewhere.

✅ Pros
  • Automatic rebalancing via pies
  • Fractional shares by default
  • $0 commissions
⚠️ Watch out
  • $100 minimum (taxable), $500 (IRA)
  • Trades execute once daily only
  • Premium features cost $3/mo
Open Account at M1 Finance →
#6 Robinhood
Simplest UX

Robinhood reduced the friction of a first ETF purchase to fewer taps than any other platform here. Fractional shares let you invest with as little as $1. Research tools are thin and gamification criticism is fair — but as a place to start a simple buy-and-hold portfolio, it works.

✅ Pros
  • Easiest interface; $0 min
  • Fractional shares from $1
  • IRA match promotion (up to 3%)
⚠️ Watch out
  • Thin research & educational tools
  • Gamification design is deliberate
  • Regulatory history worth reviewing
Open Account at Robinhood →
#7 E*TRADE
Best Research Tools

Now part of Morgan Stanley, E*TRADE brings a professional-grade research suite to retail investors. Power E*TRADE is one of the more capable desktop experiences at $0 commission. Its retirement account tools — RMD calculators, rollover guides, beneficiary management — are the most developed on this list.

✅ Pros
  • Best retirement account toolset
  • 6,500+ ETFs with solid screener
  • Up to $3,500 transfer bonus
⚠️ Watch out
  • Morgan Stanley feel; can be overwhelming
  • Platform split (E*TRADE / Power) adds confusion
Open Account at E*TRADE →
#8 Merrill Edge
Best for BofA Customers

If you already bank with Bank of America, Merrill Edge is worth a serious look. The Preferred Rewards program ties your BofA and Merrill balances together — higher tiers earn boosted credit card cash back and priority service. For everyone else, it’s solid but unremarkable.

✅ Pros
  • Preferred Rewards perks for BofA users
  • BofA Global Research library
  • Up to $600 transfer bonus
⚠️ Watch out
  • Not compelling without a BofA relationship
  • Interface less polished than Fidelity/Schwab
Open Account at Merrill Edge →
#9 Webull
Best Charting & Data

Webull’s free tier includes Level 2 quotes, advanced charting, and a desktop app most platforms charge $15–$30/month for. For buy-and-hold ETF investors who also want to watch the market, it covers both without extra cost. The trade-off is a company based in China, which some users flag as a data privacy concern.

✅ Pros
  • Free Level 2 quotes & advanced charts
  • Extended hours (4 AM–8 PM ET)
  • Paper trading mode included
⚠️ Watch out
  • China-based; some users flag data privacy
  • Thinner ETF research vs. full brokers
Open Account at Webull →
#10 tastytrade
Best Active Traders

tastytrade’s ETF commissions are $0 but its real strength is options. If you hold ETFs as your core position and layer options strategies on top, tastytrade’s platform is purpose-built for that workflow in a way nothing else is. Pure buy-and-hold investors don’t need what it specializes in.

✅ Pros
  • $0 ETF commissions
  • Lowest options commissions available
  • Up to $4,000 transfer bonus
⚠️ Watch out
  • Platform built for options, not ETF-only
  • Education content isn’t ETF-focused
Open Account at tastytrade →

How to Transfer Your Brokerage Account (Without Selling Anything)

An ACAT transfer moves your positions in-kind. Your ETFs don't get sold, your cost basis stays intact, and you don't owe taxes. Here's how it works.

ACAT stands for Automated Customer Account Transfer Service. It is the industry-standard mechanism for moving a brokerage account from one firm to another. You initiate it at the receiving brokerage (the one you're moving to), not the one you're leaving. Your existing holdings transfer as-is — you are not required to sell anything, which means no tax event and no gap in market exposure.

  1. 1 Open an account at the new brokerage. You need an account number before you can initiate a transfer.
  2. 2 At the new brokerage, find the transfer or ACAT section. This is usually under "Accounts" or "Move Money." You will need your old account number and the old brokerage's name.
  3. 3 Choose a full or partial transfer. A full transfer moves everything and closes the old account. A partial transfer lets you specify which positions to move while leaving the rest.
  4. 4 The new brokerage submits the transfer request on your behalf. Standard ACAT transfers take 5–7 business days. You may see a brief period where the assets show as pending at the new broker before they are fully settled.
  5. 5 Confirm that all positions transferred correctly and that your cost basis data transferred accurately. Cost basis does not always transfer automatically — you may need to contact the new broker to import it manually if you do not see it.
  6. 6 If you qualified for a transfer bonus, confirm the bonus posting requirements with the new broker. Most require you to maintain the transferred assets for 90–180 days.
A note on transfer bonuses: Bonus amounts, qualifying thresholds, and holding period requirements change frequently and are often not prominently advertised. Do not rely on any number listed on this page as current. Go directly to the broker's website or call their transfer team to confirm the current offer before initiating a move. If the qualifying window has closed, you are locked into the holding period with no bonus to show for it.

Ready to make the move? Here’s what’s currently on offer.

These bonuses are for investors transferring existing assets — always verify the current amount directly with each broker before initiating a transfer.

Bonus amounts and eligibility requirements change frequently. Figures shown are maximums. Confirm current terms directly on each broker’s website.

Join ETF BFF

Frequently Asked Questions

The questions we actually get. Answered in plain English.

A brokerage commission is a one-time fee you pay to execute a trade. An expense ratio is an ongoing annual fee built into the ETF itself — it is deducted from the fund's assets daily and reduces the fund's price slightly each day. You never see a direct charge; the fund just grows a little slower. If you pay $0 to buy an ETF but the ETF charges a 1% expense ratio, you are paying 1% of your total balance every single year it is held. Commissions are largely irrelevant for long-term investors now that they are $0. Expense ratios compound over decades and can cost tens of thousands of dollars. Focus on the expense ratio first.
Fidelity and Charles Schwab are consistently strong choices for beginners. Both offer $0 commissions, no account minimums, excellent educational resources, and platforms that don't feel overwhelming. Fidelity has a slight edge on fractional shares and interface clarity. Robinhood is simpler but offers thinner research tools. For someone who wants to set up a three-fund portfolio and leave it alone, any of the top-tier brokers will do the job — the differences become meaningful only as your portfolio grows or your needs get more specific. Take our ETF Archetype Quiz to figure out what kind of investor you are first.
ACAT stands for Automated Customer Account Transfer. It is the standard process for moving brokerage accounts from one firm to another. Most ACAT transfers take 5–7 business days to complete. Your existing positions transfer in-kind, meaning they are not sold and rebought. You keep your cost basis and holding period intact and owe no taxes on the transfer itself. You initiate the process at the receiving brokerage. Partial transfers (moving only specific positions) are also possible. See our step-by-step transfer guide above for the full walkthrough.
Transfer bonuses can be worth real money for larger accounts. A $500 bonus on a $50,000 transfer is a 1% immediate return with no market risk. The main caveats: bonus amounts change frequently, there are usually holding period requirements (typically 90–180 days), and you should confirm the new broker is actually a good fit for your needs before committing. Do not switch solely for a bonus that has since changed or expired. Always verify current bonus amounts and terms directly at the broker's website — bonuses are often not listed prominently and need to be found in the promotions or transfer sections.
Since commissions are $0 everywhere that matters, the real differentiators are: ETF selection breadth (especially if you want international or niche ETFs), platform quality and educational resources, fractional share availability, mobile app quality, customer service responsiveness, and the specific account types the broker supports (traditional brokerage, Roth IRA, 401k rollover, custodial accounts, etc.). For most buy-and-hold investors, the choice often comes down to interface preference and which platform you will actually stick with long enough for compounding to do its job.

What Actually Matters When Picking an ETF Brokerage

The brokerage question used to be simple: who charges the least per trade? That era is over. Commission-free ETF trading became the standard years ago, and now essentially every legitimate broker in the US charges $0 to buy and sell ETFs online. So the question has changed. The better question now is: which platform makes it easiest for you to stay invested and keep costs low over decades?

The answer starts with understanding the difference between what a brokerage charges and what your ETF charges. These are two completely separate fees that often get conflated. When a broker advertises $0 commissions, that means they are not charging you a fee to execute your buy or sell order. What they cannot change is the ETF's expense ratio — the annual fee baked into the fund itself. A 1% expense ratio on a $100,000 portfolio costs you $1,000 per year whether you hold it at Fidelity, Schwab, or anywhere else. That number compounds. Over 30 years, the gap between a 0.03% fund and a 0.75% fund can run into six figures on a meaningful portfolio. Use our ETF fee calculator to model what that looks like for your specific numbers.

The key distinction: Brokerage commissions are a one-time cost per trade and are now $0 at all major platforms. ETF expense ratios are ongoing annual costs built into the fund and apply at every brokerage. Focus on the expense ratio. The brokerage is secondary.

Account minimums used to be a real barrier. Vanguard required $3,000 to open a mutual fund account. Some brokers charged $500 or more just to get started. That has largely changed. The brokers on this page all allow you to open an account with $0 to $100. Once your account is open, fractional shares mean you can invest any dollar amount in most ETFs, even ones priced at several hundred dollars per share. The days of "I can't afford one share of SPY" are behind us for anyone using a fractional-share-enabled broker.

What does still matter, in roughly this order: the breadth of ETF selection (especially if you want exposure to international, sector-specific, or thematic ETFs that only a few brokers carry), the quality of the research and educational tools, the mobile app experience for investors who manage their portfolios from their phone, and whether the broker supports the account types you need. A Roth IRA at the wrong broker is a much bigger headache to untangle than a taxable account, so getting the account type right before you commit matters.

For investors who want to keep things simple — buy a broad market ETF, set up automatic contributions, and leave it alone for 20 years — platform sophistication barely matters. Any of the brokers in this comparison will do the job. The more important decision is picking low-cost ETFs with expense ratios under 0.10% and staying invested through volatility. No brokerage can do that part for you. What a good brokerage does is get out of your way while you do it.

One last thing worth understanding: SIPC insurance. Every brokerage listed here is a member of the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC), which protects up to $500,000 in securities (including $250,000 in cash) if a brokerage firm fails. This is not insurance against investment losses — if your ETF drops in value, SIPC does not cover that. It covers the rare event that a brokerage firm itself goes under and client assets go missing. All the major brokers are also FINRA-regulated, which means they are subject to oversight and regular examination. Picking a regulated, FINRA-member broker is table stakes. Everything on this list qualifies.

Educational content only. This page is designed to help you understand how to evaluate ETF brokerages. It does not constitute financial advice, investment recommendations, or personalized guidance. ETF BFF is not a registered investment advisor and has no financial relationship with any brokerage listed. Brokerage features, commissions, bonuses, and account minimums change frequently — always verify current terms directly at each broker's official website before opening an account or initiating a transfer. Past transfer bonuses are not indicative of future offers. Always conduct your own research and consult a qualified financial professional before making investment decisions.