🤝 BFF Take
VDC Has Better Breadth — XLF Has More Trading Volume for Tactical Use
XLP (Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR) and VDC (Vanguard Consumer Staples ETF) are both excellent consumer staples ETFs at nearly identical, rock-bottom fees. XLP holds 38 S&P 500 consumer staples companies — Procter & Gamble, Costco, Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, and Walmart dominate. VDC holds ~100 companies including mid-cap and smaller consumer staples not in the S&P 500. Both charge essentially the same: XLP 0.09%, VDC 0.10%. Consumer staples is the classic defensive sector — people buy toothpaste, food, and household goods regardless of economic conditions. XLP's higher trading volume ($600M+/day) makes it the preferred institutional hedging vehicle. VDC's broader index adds diversification into mid-cap consumer staples companies. For long-term defensive positioning, either works well.
📋 Quick Takeaways
🛒XLP holds 38 S&P 500 staples; VDC holds ~100 — P&G, Costco, Coca-Cola, PepsiCo dominate both
💰XLP 0.09% vs VDC 0.10% — effectively the same fee; both are among the cheapest sector ETFs available
🛡️Consumer staples are defensive — low beta, 2-3% yield, steady demand regardless of economic cycle
📊 Data-Based Take: VDC has the lower fee
Whether the lower-cost fund suits your situation depends on your existing holdings, account type, tax situation, and how you use each fund. This is a cost comparison, not a personalized recommendation.
✓
Reviewed by a CFA® Charterholder · Data updated Jun 2026 · Educational only, not financial advice
XLP
Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund
VDC
Vanguard Consumer Staples ETF
📋 XLP vs VDC — Key Facts Side by Side
| Metric |
XLP |
VDC |
| Fund Name |
Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund |
Vanguard Consumer Staples ETF |
| Issuer |
State Street |
Vanguard |
| Tracks Index |
Consumer Staples Select Sector Index |
MSCI US IMI Consumer Staples 25/50 |
| Expense Ratio |
0.09% ✓ |
0.10% |
| Cost per $10K/yr |
$9.00 |
$10.00 |
| AUM |
$14B |
$7B |
| Holdings |
38 |
100 |
| Inception |
1998 |
2004 |
| 1-Year Return |
+8.40% |
+9.20% |
| 3-Year Return |
+4.80% |
+5.20% |
| 5-Year Return |
+9.60% |
+9.80% |
| Avg Bid-Ask Spread |
0.01% |
0.01% |
Data from ETF BFF database. Returns are annualised. Not investment advice.
📊 XLP vs VDC — Annualised Returns
Annualised returns (trailing, price-based). Past performance does not guarantee future results.
🎯 Should You Buy XLP or VDC?
Choose if...
XLP
- You want the lowest fees — saves ~$1/yr per $10K vs VDC
- You already use State Street and prefer staying within their fund family
Choose if...
VDC
- You want broader diversification (100 holdings vs 38)
- You already use Vanguard and prefer staying within their fund family
📧 Free Weekly Newsletter
Time sectors better — the weekly ETF BFF breakdown
Cyclicals vs defensives, when to rotate, and what the macro signals are saying — clear and jargon-free.
✅ You're in! Check your inbox for your first issue.
❓ XLP vs VDC — Frequently Asked Questions
Is XLP or VDC better for a defensive portfolio?
Both are excellent — the practical difference for most investors is minimal. VDC's broader index (100 vs 38 holdings) adds mid-cap consumer staples diversification. XLP's higher trading volume makes it better for tactical positions and options strategies. For a buy-and-hold defensive allocation, VDC's additional breadth at the same price is a slight advantage. Neither will significantly outperform the other over long periods.
What is in consumer staples ETFs?
Consumer staples ETFs hold companies that produce essential everyday goods: food and beverage companies (Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, Kraft Heinz, Mondelez), household products (Procter & Gamble, Colgate-Palmolive, Kimberly-Clark), tobacco (Philip Morris, Altria), and discount retailers (Costco, Walmart). These businesses have inelastic demand — consumers continue buying their products through recessions, making them defensive holdings.
Do consumer staples ETFs hold up in market crashes?
Consumer staples are among the best-performing sectors in equity bear markets. In 2022, XLP fell roughly 3% while the S&P 500 fell 18%. In the 2020 COVID crash, staples outperformed significantly. The defensive characteristics come from: stable demand, pricing power (brands can raise prices), and recurring revenue from essential goods. The tradeoff is that staples underperform in bull markets when cyclical/growth sectors lead.
What dividend yield do XLP and VDC pay?
Both XLP and VDC typically yield 2-3% from the dividends of staples companies. This is lower than utilities (3-4%) but higher than tech sector ETFs. The dividend income is stable and growing slowly — P&G, Coca-Cola, and other staples companies are Dividend Aristocrats (25+ years of consecutive dividend increases). The yield combined with defensive characteristics makes staples ETFs attractive for income and capital preservation.
How does consumer staples compare to consumer discretionary?
Consumer staples (XLP/VDC) hold essential everyday goods companies. Consumer discretionary (XLY, VCR) holds companies selling non-essential items — Amazon, Tesla, Nike, McDonald's, Home Depot. Discretionary is cyclical — it outperforms in economic expansions and falls in recessions. Staples are the opposite — outperform defensively in downturns, lag in bull markets. Many balanced investors hold both to get full consumer sector coverage.
New to ETF investing? See answers to the most common ETF questions →
ℹ️ Data shown is for educational purposes and may not reflect the most current figures. Returns are trailing price-based and exclude dividend reinvestment. Past performance does not guarantee future results. ETF BFF is not a licensed financial advisor — this is not personalized financial advice.