SCHD vs VYM Overlap: Dividend Quality vs Dividend Yield
SCHD holds ~100 stocks screened for dividend consistency, cash flow, and payout ratio. VYM holds 400+ stocks ranked by yield. They share some names but are built on different selection logic.
What the SCHD and VYM Overlap Means
SCHD and VYM are both dividend ETFs, but they apply different logic to select holdings. SCHD (Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF) screens a universe of dividend-paying US stocks using four quality factors: cash flow to debt, return on equity, dividend yield relative to peers, and five-year dividend growth rate. The result is roughly 100 high-quality dividend payers. VYM (Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF) takes a simpler approach: rank US stocks by dividend yield, exclude REITs, and hold the top half — roughly 400 to 450 stocks.
These different selection methods produce some shared holdings, but the top 10 lists diverge. Both funds hold blue-chip dividend payers, but SCHD is more concentrated in its top names and more selective about quality. VYM is broader and more yield-focused. The funds have different sector tilts: SCHD typically has higher financials and lower utilities exposure than VYM.
These funds are more complementary than redundant. Owning both gives you broader dividend coverage — SCHD's quality screen combined with VYM's breadth. The overlap in top holdings is moderate, and the funds serve slightly different roles: SCHD for quality income with growth potential, VYM for broad dividend exposure with lower volatility from individual companies.
Get our weekly ETF takes.
One email per week. The ETF research, fund mechanics, and portfolio decisions that actually matter. No noise, no sales pitch.
Top-10 holdings data, updated regularly from public sources. Shared position counts reflect top-10 positions only — not full portfolio overlap. For broad market funds like VTI and VOO, true full-portfolio overlap is significantly higher than the top-10 figure. Nothing here is personalized financial advice. Full disclosures.
Frequently Asked Questions
Partially. Both hold well-known dividend payers, and some names appear in both funds. However, SCHD's quality screens (~100 stocks) and VYM's yield-based selection (~450 stocks) produce meaningfully different portfolios. The top-10 overlap is typically 3-5 names. They share exposure to large dividend-paying blue chips but diverge in selection logic and sector weights.
SCHD has outperformed VYM on total return over most 10-year windows, largely because its quality screens (cash flow, return on equity) filter out weaker dividend payers before they cut their dividends. VYM is more diversified with ~450 holdings vs SCHD's ~100, which reduces individual stock risk. SCHD for better historical total return; VYM for broader exposure and lower concentration risk.
You can, and there is more logic to it than owning two funds that are nearly identical (like VOO and SPY). SCHD's quality filter and VYM's breadth are genuinely complementary. However, most investors do not need both — pick based on whether you prioritize dividend quality and total return (SCHD) or broader yield and diversification (VYM).
SCHD selects ~100 stocks based on four quality criteria: cash flow to total debt, return on equity, dividend yield relative to peers, and five-year dividend growth rate. VYM selects ~450 stocks primarily by dividend yield, with looser quality requirements. SCHD is more concentrated and quality-focused; VYM is broader and yield-focused.
It varies by period. Historically VYM has had a higher trailing yield (around 3-3.5%), but SCHD has closed the gap and sometimes leads. More important than current yield is yield on cost after several years — SCHD's dividend growth rate has historically been higher, which means investors who held SCHD for 5-10 years often have a higher yield on their original cost basis than VYM holders.