No. Nothing about the ETF wrapper makes a price go up. An ETF rises when the things inside it rise and falls when they fall. Broad US stock funds have gone up over every 20-year stretch on record, and they have also lost a third of their value in five weeks. Both facts are true at once, and the second one is the price of the first.
The belief that ETFs "always go up" usually comes from looking at a chart of VOO that starts in 2010. That chart shows one of the best runs in market history. Start the same chart in 2000 and the first thirteen years are flat.
An ETF is a wrapper, not an investment
An ETF is a container. VTI holds about 3,600 US stocks. BND holds US bonds. TQQQ holds a leveraged bet on 100 tech-heavy companies. All three are ETFs and they have almost nothing else in common. Asking whether ETFs go up is like asking whether boxes are heavy. It depends entirely on what is in the box, which is why how the fund is built matters more than the three letters after its name.
The record, including the bad parts
| What happened | How bad | How long to recover |
|---|---|---|
| S&P 500, early 2020 | About -34% in five weeks | About five months |
| S&P 500, 2022 | About -25% peak to trough | About two years |
| S&P 500, 2000 to 2013 | Two crashes of roughly half | Thirteen years to stay above the 2000 high |
| US bonds (BND), 2022 | About -13% for the year | Years, not months |
| Japan's Nikkei 225 | Peaked December 1989 | 34 years, until 2024 |
The Japan row is the one worth sitting with. A broad index of a major developed economy peaked and did not see that level again for a generation. It is the standing counterexample to "the market always comes back if you wait," and it is the best argument for not betting everything on one country.
The bond row surprises people too. Bond funds are sold as the calm part of a portfolio, and 2022 was the worst calendar year in the history of the main US bond index, because rates rose fast. "Safe" described the credit quality, not the price.
The whole plan on one page: the 3-Fund Starter Kit
The three funds, a common allocation by life stage, and the exact tickers at Vanguard, Fidelity, Schwab, and M1, on one printable page.
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime · Your download opens instantly
Your download is ready above. You are also subscribed to The Expense Report, our weekly ETF newsletter. Watch your inbox for an email from ETF BFF.
What has actually held up
Here is the part the pessimists skip. The S&P 500 has fallen 20% or more nine times since 1950 and recovered from all nine. Over every rolling 20-year period on record, US large-cap stocks finished higher than they started. The pattern is not "always up." It is "up over long periods, with regular and sometimes brutal interruptions." Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Three things have improved the odds historically, and none of them is a secret:
- Breadth. Thousands of companies across many countries, so no single failure or single economy decides the outcome.
- Time. Money needed in two years and money needed in twenty are different problems. The record favors the second.
- Not selling at the bottom. A decline is a paper loss until shares are sold. We cover that in is it normal for your ETF to drop.
The answer changes with the kind of ETF
- Broad stock index funds (VTI, VOO, VT): the long record above applies, drops included.
- Bond funds: steadier most years, but they fall when interest rates rise.
- Sector and thematic funds: a single industry can stay down for a decade. See sector ETFs.
- Leveraged and inverse funds: built to lose value over time in choppy markets. See leveraged ETFs.
Anyone who tells you ETFs always go up is selling something or started investing after 2009. The honest pitch is less exciting and more useful: a broad, cheap fund has been the most reliable way for ordinary people to own the long-run growth of business, and the cost of admission is sitting through years that look like failure. If a 30% drop would force you to sell, the fund is not the problem. The amount in it is.
Do ETFs always go up?
- No. An ETF moves with whatever it holds; the wrapper adds no upward force.
- Broad US stock funds have dropped a third in weeks (2020) and gone nowhere for 13 years (2000 to 2013).
- Bonds fell about 13% in 2022. Japan's main index took 34 years to regain its 1989 peak.
- The S&P 500 has recovered from all nine declines of 20% or more since 1950. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
- Breadth, time, and not selling at the bottom are what the long record rewards. Sector and leveraged funds follow different rules.
Common questions
No. An ETF rises and falls with the investments it holds. Broad US stock ETFs have risen over every 20-year period on record, but they have also fallen by a third in a matter of weeks and gone more than a decade without a lasting new high. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This is general educational information, not advice.
Broad stock index ETFs have historically risen over long periods because they hold thousands of businesses that grow earnings over time. That record includes long flat stretches, such as US stocks from 2000 to 2013, and it does not extend to every fund. Narrow sector funds, leveraged funds, and single-country funds have stayed down for a decade or longer.
Yes. Any ETF can fall below the price you paid. Stock ETFs fall in market downturns, bond ETFs fall when interest rates rise, and leveraged ETFs can lose most of their value. A broad index ETF going to zero would require every company it holds to fail at once.
It depends on what it holds. The S&P 500 recovered from its 2020 drop in about five months and took about two years after 2022. After the 2000 peak it did not stay above that level until 2013. Japan's Nikkei 225 took 34 years to regain its 1989 high.